How We Score: The Prime Score™ Methodology

Complete transparency on how we evaluate every beef delivery company in America.

🏪 the Costco Standard

We use Costco as the universal baseline because it offers consistent USDA-graded beef at delivered prices (Costco.com). Every value comparison is made against these benchmarks:

Ground Beef 85/15
$6.50/lb
Choice Ribeye
$16/lb
Prime Ribeye
$22/lb
Prime NY Strip
$18/lb

This is the ruler everything else is measured against. When we say a company charges "3x Costco prices," this is what we mean.

🥩The Cut (×2 weight)

Meat quality, marbling, taste, texture — the stuff that actually matters when you take a bite.

Our Sources:

  • • Trustpilot reviews and ratings
  • • Reddit discussions (r/steak, r/mealprep, r/butcherbox)
  • • Food media reviews and taste tests
  • • YouTube blind taste tests
  • • Community feedback and chef opinions
10 = Life-changing
Restaurant-quality, perfect marbling
5 = Grocery store quality
Decent, nothing special
1 = Disappointing
Tough, flavorless, poor quality

💰The Deal (×2 weight)

Price per pound vs. Costco. This score is MATH, not opinion.

10
At/below Costco prices
7
Up to 50% more
5
50-100% more
3
200%+ more (2x Costco)
1
Price gouging

Example: If Costco ribeye is $22/lb and a company charges $33/lb, that's 3x more expensive = Score of 2-3.

🔍The Truth (×1 weight)

Sourcing transparency. Can you name the farm? Are grass-fed claims verifiable? Are USDA grades real?

10 = Farm-identified
Every claim verified, traceable sourcing
5 = Vague claims
"Quality" without specifics
1 = No verification
Impossible to verify anything

📦📦 Delivery (×1 weight)

Shipping reliability based on community reports. Arrives frozen solid? Packaging integrity? On-time rate?

10 = Consistently perfect
Always arrives frozen, pristine packaging
5 = Occasional issues
Usually good, sometimes problems
1 = Regular disasters
Thawed meat, damaged packages

👥The People (×1 weight)

Customer service — do they make it right when something goes wrong?

Based on:

  • • Trustpilot customer service reviews
  • • Better Business Bureau complaints and resolutions
  • • Reddit complaint threads and outcomes
  • • Response time and resolution quality
10 = Problems solved fast
Immediate refunds, no questions asked
5 = Hit or miss
Sometimes helpful, sometimes not
1 = Good luck
Getting a refund is a battle

🔓The Freedom (×1 weight)

Subscription flexibility. How easy is it to pause, skip, or cancel?

10
A-la-carte, no commitment ever
7
Easy pause/cancel
4
Technically possible but difficult
1
You're locked in

🌿Natural (×2 weight)

Antibiotic-free + hormone/steroid-free + no artificial additives. The clean eating factor.

10 = Never-ever program
No antibiotics, hormones, or additives ever
7 = No added hormones
May treat sick animals therapeutically
5 = Standard USDA
No specific natural claims

🧮 Prime Score™ Formula

(Cut×2 + Value×2 + Truth + Delivery + People + Freedom + Natural×2) ÷ 10

Cut, Value, and Natural scores are weighted 2x — Cut and Value drive purchase decisions, Natural reflects health priorities — quality and price drive 95% of purchase decisions.

Grade Scale
9.0+ = A+
8.0+ = A
7.0+ = B+
6.0+ = B
5.0+ = C
<5.0 = D
Update Schedule
Scores are reviewed and updated quarterly based on new reviews, price changes, and service quality reports.
Our Limits
We haven't tasted every product. Some scores are based on limited community data. Always read individual reviews.

🤝 Full Transparency

Data Sources: Our scores are based on public information, community reviews, and aggregated feedback from real customers across Trustpilot, Reddit, YouTube, and food media.

Affiliate Relationships: We earn commission when you purchase through our affiliate links. This never influences our scores — we rank companies by data, not payout rates.

Testing Limitations: We haven't personally taste-tested every single product from every company. Some scores are based on community consensus and limited sampling.

Score Updates: Companies can improve their scores by improving their service, pricing, or transparency. We update scores quarterly based on new data.

Questions about our methodology?

Want to suggest improvements or report inaccurate data? We're always looking to make our scoring better.

Browse All CompaniesHow We Track Prices